Metropolis gasoline distributors Indraprastha Gasoline Ltd (IGL) and Mahanagar Gasoline Ltd (MGL) have suffered two consecutive blows in a month. The federal government has lowered the provision of cheaper pure gasoline by 20% for IGL and 18% for MGL, efficient 16 November. This follows a earlier discount of 21% for IGL and 20% for MGL, efficient 16 October.
Cumulatively, the minimize is round 36% every from the unique allocation made a month in the past, because the manufacturing of domestically equipped gasoline below the executive value mechanism (APM) has declined. Consequently, MGL and IGL shares have misplaced steam, falling 14% and 20%, respectively during the last two buying and selling periods.
The worth and supply from which these corporations meet the shortfall are essential now. For perspective, APM gasoline is priced at $6.5 per mmbtu and non-APM home gasoline at $8-9 per mmbtu. Spot LNG is even greater at $14 per mmbtu. Within the September quarter (Q2FY25), whereas IGL’s gasoline sourcing consisted of fifty% APM gasoline, for MGL it was 71% given the former’s bigger gross sales quantity.
To take care of FY25 Ebitda margin steerage of ₹6- ₹7 per customary cubic meter (scm), IGL must elevate the worth of compressed pure gasoline (CNG). The administration had indicated a rise of ₹5-6 per kilogram after the primary discount of 21% in October. This could rise additional after the second minimize in APM gasoline provide, assuming the utilization of regasified LNG purchased from short-term tendering.
MGL’s guided vary of Ebitda per scm of ₹10-12 for FY25 can be in danger if it doesn’t enhance costs or discover low-cost pure gasoline provide. IGL’s comparatively decrease base margins than MGL means it must hike costs extra desperately than MGL.
The worth enhance could should be smaller as the federal government might present some assist within the type of both decrease excise responsibility or placing it below the GST regime. Presently, the central authorities levies a 14% excise responsibility on CNG. As the federal government needs to extend the share of pure gasoline within the complete power basket from 7% at current to fifteen% by 2030, some aid on the excise responsibility entrance can’t be dominated out.
Additionally Learn: Progress issues: Analysing MGL’s investor sentiment
CNG vs conventional fuels
However is it attainable to take care of Ebitda margin with out sacrificing volumes to different fuels equivalent to petrol and diesel? Understanding the economics of gasoline turns into essential right here. Petrol and diesel are offered in litres and CNG in kilogram. Presently, CNG is priced cheaper in comparison with petrol and diesel by at the very least 10-15%, with some variation in Delhi, Uttar Pradesh and Haryana, the place the IGL has its operations.
For MGL, which primarily operates in Mumbai and Thane, CNG’s low cost to petrol and diesel is within the vary of 10-20%. Even when all three are priced on the similar stage, CNG nonetheless gives benefits of comparatively clear gasoline and operational effectivity when it comes to greater mileage.
In the meantime, IGL and MGL managements have said that they’re evaluating value hikes for CNG, however haven’t finalized something thus far. The uncertainty retains these shares uncovered to additional earnings downgrades. In CY24 thus far, MGL’s inventory is down 6%, whereas IGL has declined 23%.
There’s a lurking menace from electrical autos and issues over sustainability of margins stays. Then again, if these corporations can supply pure gasoline on a long-term foundation, both from non-APM blocks domestically or from imports, there’s potential for some revival in shares.
Additionally Learn: IGL seeks renewable power property because it appears to show web zero
