The declare: ‘All prices’ in Trump hush cash case ‘dropped’ as of Nov. 19, 2024
A Nov. 20 Instagram put up (direct link, archive link) reveals pictures of New York Decide Juan Merchan, President-elect Donald Trump and Manhattan District Lawyer Alvin Bragg.
“BREAKING: Donald Trump’s sentencing for 34 felony prices within the state of New York abruptly adjourned by Decide Merchan with out clarification. All prices have been dropped,” reads textual content within the picture, which is a screenshot of a Nov. 19 post on X, formerly Twitter. “The Lawfare towards Trump is over!”
A model of the declare posted to Instagram obtained greater than 1,000 likes in lower than a day earlier than it was deleted. Variations of the declare additionally circulated extensively on Facebook and TikTok.
Extra from the Truth-Examine Crew: How we choose and analysis claims | Email newsletter | Facebook page
Our score: False
The case was paused following the presidential election however was not “dropped” or dismissed when the unique put up was shared. On the day the put up was made, a Trump legal professional requested Merchan for 30 days to kind a extra strong argument for dismissal.
Trump case paused, not dismissed, when put up was shared
Trump was discovered responsible in Might of 34 counts of falsifying enterprise information to hide a hush cash cost to grownup movie actress Stormy Daniels forward of the 2016 presidential election. Merchan put Trump’s sentencing on maintain after Trump gained a second presidential time period, and attorneys for the president-elect need that conviction tossed out totally.
However when the X put up was shared, that request had not been formally made, a lot much less granted. Nor are there any reviews from reputable media retailers a few dismissal on or earlier than Nov. 19.
Truth test: Trump jury needed to be unanimous in hush cash trial to search out him responsible
As a substitute, in a letter that day to Merchan, Trump legal professional Todd Blanche previewed his argument for tossing out the case. Its “quick dismissal” is constitutionally mandated, he wrote, “to facilitate the orderly transition of govt energy” after the election. He requested Merchan for permission to file a proper, extra full movement to dismiss the case by Dec. 20. Had Trump’s conviction already been “dropped,” because the put up claims, that transfer would make no sense.
The social media posts and others like them word the adjournment however seem to mischaracterize exactly what which means on this context. The proceedings have been paused or postponed, not summarily dropped at an finish, as is made clear in a set of Nov. 10 emails from attorneys on either side.
Assistant District Lawyer Matthew Colangelo asked Merchan for a stay in gentle of the unprecedented circumstances of a president-elect going through felony sentencing whereas his inauguration approaches. The topic line of his e-mail references a “request for adjournment.” Trump legal professional Emil Bove replied to precise the president-elect’s need to affix the request, which was made public Nov. 12. Stephen Suhovsky, Merchan’s principal law clerk, then notified the attorneys that Merchan granted the keep and advised prosecutors to elucidate their most well-liked subsequent steps by Nov. 19.
In his Nov. 19letter to Merchan, Bragg beneficial that Merchan set a schedule for Trump’s attorneys to submit their formal request for a dismissal, then give prosecutors till Dec. 9 to reply. He additionally stated he plans to oppose their request and helps adjourning all different elements of the case till the dismissal request is determined.USA TODAY beforehand debunked false claims that Merchan was “fired” and that not solely was Trump’s conviction “overturned” in October however he was additionally awarded a refund of $500 million.
USA TODAY reached out to a number of social media customers who shared the declare however didn’t instantly obtain any responses.
Our fact-check sources
Thanks for supporting our journalism. You’ll be able to subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or e-newspaper here.
USA TODAY is a verified signatory of the Worldwide Truth-Checking Community, which requires a demonstrated dedication to nonpartisanship, equity and transparency. Our fact-check work is supported partially by a grant from Meta.
( headline and story edited by our workers and is printed from a syndicated feed.)
