There are lots of methods during which one can start a brand new 12 months with a weekly column. It will probably contain outlining the fundamental fault traces within the 12 months that will probably be; that is one thing this column usually does, making predictions for the 12 months forward; this the column not often does, and even outlining a want checklist. In another 12 months, these would have been believable choices for the new-year version of this column. Nonetheless, 2025 is a particular 12 months for Indian political economic system. In any case, it marks the completion of a protracted arc of historical past of two mutually opposed political initiatives in trendy India. On 17 September this 12 months, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) will full 100 years. Three months later, on December 26, it will likely be hundred years because the formation of the Communist Celebration of India (CPI).
Ironic as it could sound within the case of the RSS, it was as trendy a political mission because the CPI was, and drew its inspiration not from India’s historical heritage and tradition however the ethnic-nationalist political thought and nation-states in up to date Europe on the time of its founding. How ought to one consider these two political initiatives of the left and the appropriate in India hundred years after they began? In some ways, there is just one clear winner on this story.
After a long time of ups and downs and ideological confusion and compromises — the BJP’s predecessor Jan Sangh usually did enterprise with the Communists at one level of time and even the BJP and communists had been supporting a Nationwide Entrance authorities in 1989 — the RSS’s political clout – it’s manifested via its political arm BJP – broke new floor within the Nineteen Eighties to get right into a rising trajectory. The BJP has ended up as the one largest social gathering in all however two nationwide elections since 1996. It achieved back-to-back parliamentary majorities within the 2014 and 2019 elections and has managed to seize energy for the third consecutive time in 2024 on the premise of a pre-poll coalition. By all means, the BJP is the dominant political drive within the nation.
What makes the post-2014 part of the BJP’s dominance much more particular from the RSS’s perspective is the truth that the previous has managed to seize government energy with out having to dilute the core ideological agenda of the RSS not like within the Nineteen Nineties. We have already got a Ram temple in Ayodhya, Article 370 has been abrogated from the structure and a whole lot of BJP-ruled states are already taking part in with the thought of state stage uniform civil codes. With the core trifecta already in sight, the RSS and its associates couldn’t have requested for a greater option to attain their hundred-year-mark.
The Communists, however, are ending their centenary 12 months on a really completely different notice. They’re a marginalised electoral drive within the nation in the present day. On a strictly self-sufficient foundation, they’re in energy in only one state of the nation, specifically, Kerala. To make sure, their greatest adversity has been a worldwide relatively than nationwide political occasion. The disintegration of the Soviet Union introduced an finish to the socialist mission which had impressed and guided the formation of communist events, some even made revolutions, throughout the globe, together with in India. In some ways, this has raised critical questions in regards to the raison d’être of communist events, that are nonetheless, at the least on a de-jure foundation, programmatically dedicated to creating a revolution. No communist social gathering or chief in the present day critically believes within the prospect of such a revolution of their lifetime.
To make sure, what makes the Indian communist mission particular is the truth that not solely did it survive the disintegration of the Soviet camp, it even managed to extend its electoral power in its aftermath, a lot in order that the communists had been virtually on the cusp of getting the prime minister’s put up in 1996. Additionally they grew to become a key pillar of the union authorities from 2004 to 2008. Since then, it has been a downhill trip to close self-extinction. It’s only pure that the electoral debacle of the final 20 years is of a lot greater curiosity to the Indian communists than ideological questions in regards to the relevance and feasibility of socialism per se of their centenary 12 months.
Past these apparent empirical observations, is there one thing extra to be mentioned about hundred years of the communist-left and Hindu-right political initiatives in India?
Each these initiatives have needed to take care of an inherent contradiction particular to Indian circumstances of their in any other case monolithic polarisation designs: the bulk Hindus within the RSS’s case and the proverbial proletariat in case of the communists. This contradiction has been caste, which is exclusive to Hinduism however has additionally permeated into different religions in India. The caste contradiction in politics grew to become an increasing number of pronounced as India adopted a common franchise-based democracy after independence and it steadily modified the character of electoral competitors.
It’s not a mere coincidence that each the RSS and the Communists got here up with what could be described as their most important treatise on navigating the caste query within the Seventies, by which period, post-independence polity and the Congress dominance each had been in a state of flux and caste was a significant driver of this political churning.
For the RSS this was conveyed within the 1974 Vasant Vyakhyanmala lecture on Social Equality and Hindu Consolidation by the then RSS chief Balasahab Deoras which unambiguously declared that caste discrimination was an anathema to RSS’s purpose of reaching Hindu consolidation. “Could all of us really feel that the Hindus should unite and that for his or her unity the premise can solely be social equality”, Deoras mentioned within the lecture, making a transparent enchantment to the in any other case conservative base of his organisation for the sake of political survival.
For the communists, the road got here from a 1979 Financial and Political Weekly article referred to as Caste, Class and Property Relations by B T Ranadive. Ranadive, or BTR, as he was popularly identified, was one of many senior-most Communist Celebration of India (Marxist) or CPI (M) leaders and a former normal secretary of the undivided CPI who had given the notorious armed wrestle line to the social gathering after 1947; it was subsequently withdrawn later.
BTR’s line was extra vanguardist than persuasive. “The consciousness of the victims (decrease castes) is nonetheless lagging behind this actuality. As a substitute of a typical wrestle it seems as if the caste-struggles are reaching a brand new crescendo, castes look like pitted in opposition to one another as by no means earlier than, and civil strife appears to be the order of the day…It’s sheer deception to think about abolishing untouchability or caste with the landlords and monopolists dominating the economic system and bourgeois landlord authorities in energy”, it mentioned, in a method articulating that the wrestle in opposition to caste inequality needed to be a subset of the one in opposition to class inequality.
Is the RSS’s success and the communists’ failure in advancing their political fortunes only a reflection of their means to promote their “line” on caste inside their rank and file and the specified goal base? Sure information make it very tempting to reply this query in affirmative.
The Babri mosque in Ayodhya was demolished beneath the watch of a BJP chief minister who got here from an OBC sub-caste. Narendra Modi, who’s by far the most well-liked chief the BJP has ever had, is himself an OBC. Most electoral surveys and, extra importantly, legislative illustration information present that BJP enjoys appreciable assist among the many ranks of the non-upper castes in massive components of the nation. It’s now not the Baniya-Brahmin social gathering of yesteryears.
The communists, however, first misplaced to caste-based events in North India after which misplaced their greatest bastion of West Bengal the place their regime was seen as a clique of higher caste Hindu Bengalis. To make sure, each the long-term and rapid triggers for his or her loss in Bengal had been rooted extra in school than caste. That they’ve survived in Kerala, the place the second-generation management of the social gathering had been OBCs relatively than higher castes is yet one more reality in assist of this argument.
Additionally Learn: CPI chief seeks Kerala ADGP’s elimination over ‘secret’ RSS assembly
To leap to a caste-explains-it-all thesis on the fundamental of such proof, nonetheless, could be a mistake. The class of sophistication continues to be related in Indian political competitors and you’ll solely ignore it at your personal threat. The most important argument in assist of such skepticism is that there’s a widespread convergence by way of caste-agnostic class-palliatives throughout political events in India in the present day. They embrace not simply caste-agnostic money switch or revenue assist schemes however even a dilution of caste-based reservations to increase affirmative motion to the poor amongst so-called higher castes. Actually, the loss in BJP’s parliamentary power in 2024 elections may very properly be attributed to a scarcity of sophistication relatively than identification objects in its electoral pitch. This column has usually described this vulnerability of the BJP as hegemony with out dominance.
There’s a extra fascinating and tough to reply query vis-à-vis these two political initiatives in India, which is the next. Is there a elementary asymmetry between the efficacy and flexibility of political praxis of those two political ideologies within the nation?
The RSS and its political arm BJP can usurp the electoral democracy model of sophistication wrestle by providing financial palliatives together with their core identification politics. However the Communists are unable to strike this steadiness vis-a-vis identification whereas making an attempt to additional class wrestle, both in its revisionist or radical kinds. Except the Communists can provide you with an out-of-the-box resolution to this constraint, one can not however surmise that the way forward for Indian political competitors will principally reconfigure itself on the traces of conservative and not-so-conservative social democratic poles the place fiscal palliatives would be the widespread issue and identification the differentiating one. The RSS’s political mission will signify the previous and revel in a bonus due to its means to marry class and caste with its majoritarian identification mission.
Roshan Kishore, HT’s Knowledge and Political Economic system Editor, writes a weekly column on the state of the nation’s economic system and its political fall out, and vice-versa
